The Gathering House at Pilgrim Plaza

Room to gather. Space to breathe. Cape May done beautifully.

Inquire Today

The Gathering House at Pilgrim Plaza

Where Family & Friends Gather, Memories Are Made, and Cape May Adventures Begin.

Spacious, welcoming, and designed for connection, The Gathering House at 610 Pilgrim Plaza is your North Cape May retreat for meaningful time together. Sleeping up to 10 guests, this pet-friendly home offers room to spread out, gather around the kitchen island, share sunset walks by the bay, and create the kind of memories that last long after summer ends.

Whether you’re planning a multi-generational vacation, a milestone birthday, or a long-overdue girls weekend, this is a home built for togetherness. Also in a good location for Coast Guard Graduation.

Plan Your Stay at The Gathering House

Perfect for:

• Large families
• Milestone birthdays
• Girls weekends
• Multi-generational stays

Highlights:

• Sleeps 10
• Pet friendly
• Easy access to beach & local attractions
• Open kitchen for gathering

Reserve Now

This isn’t just a beach rental. It’s a curated coastal wine experience

Enhance your stay with a private, curated wine tasting experience available exclusively for guests.

Reserve Now
Explore Wine Experiences

Why Book Direct?

• No platform service fees
• Direct communication with your host
• Access to exclusive wine experiences
• Best availability for peak summer weeks

Book Direct & Save

Bedroom 4 1 Full 1 twin bunk

Bedroom Twin Bunk

Twin Bunk Room

Hall Bathroom

Hall bathroom

The Retro Room – Full Bed

Master Bedroom Queen Bed

Master Bath

Master Bath

Open Kitchen Living Area

Game Room

Backyard

Street View

Open Kitchen Living Area

Open Kitchen Living Area

Testimonials

Amanda J - Stayed 4 nights in Aug 2025

It was great! Close to the beach, wineries and distilleries. Loved that we could bring our dogs and there was a fenced in backyard!

Ponnu - Stayed 3 Nights August 2026

Debbie and Paul’s place was just what we needed for a few days in Cape May. Everything was as listed, and Debbie was very responsive from booking through our stay. We appreciated the hospitality! Our kids especially loved playing air hockey. The neighborhood is quiet and peaceful, close to amenities and 10 minutes from Cape May Beaches.

Michelle C - Stayed 5 Nights August 2026

My family and I had a beautiful stay in this home. The hosts were excellent – easy communication.

Tori G - Stayed 7 night August 2026

A great space for a family to gather 🙂

Click Here

Andrew B - Stayed 3 nights July 2026

Great place to stay, centrally located so easy to get to supermarket, beach, old Cape May and Wildwood. Debbie was great to communicate with. Overall had a fantastic time!

Click Here

Tiffany I - Stayed 3 nights in Sep 2025

Pet friendly and family friendly. Beach was in walking distance. In town for Coast Guard graduation, so unfortunately didn’t get to stay long but would definitely look into this property again when coming back. Very helpful and accommodating hosts. Really enjoyed it.

Felicia P - Stayed 4 nights in Sep 2025

We had a very nice time. The neighborhood is so cute, we went for walks every day and night. The kitchen is well-equipped with everything you might need. The whole house was clean and the bedrooms are not on top of each other. It has a very good layout and fenced in yard. We walked to the nearby beach and it was a short drive to Washington Street and the touristy spots.would stay here again.

Donna C - Stayed 7 nights in Jul 2025

Loved our trip down memory lane. Our grandkids got to experience what our family vacations had been! We revisited all of our favorite Cape May and Wildwood spots! Now that we all live in SC, it was a great experience and location to do all the things we wanted!

Copyright © 2026 Divi. All Rights Reserved.